| 1944
Rex Supply Co |
 Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Allspice / Pimento · Bay Rum · Bitter Orange · Cedar · Cinnamon +12 other notes
|
2 |
| Agnostico
Bullfrog |
 Leather / Tobacco / Smoky |
West Indian Bay · Anise · Lemon · Nutmeg · Pink Pepper · Geranium +12 other notes
|
3 |
| American 250
Barberry Coast Shave Co. Limited |
 Amber / Resinous |
West Indian Bay · Bergamot · Mandarin · Coriander Seed · Leather · Mahogany +8 other notes
|
5 |
| Apple Bourbon Bay Rum
Ethos Grooming Essentials |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Apple · Bourbon · Allspice / Pimento · Bay Rum · Cinnamon +9 other notes
|
1 |
| Atomic Age Bay Rum
Phoenix Artisan Accoutrements |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Beeswax · Bay Rum · Citrus (unspecified) · Coconut · Dry +10 other notes
|
5 |
| Atomic Pumpkin
Phoenix Artisan Accoutrements |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Elemi · Allspice / Pimento · Bay Rum · Blood Orange · Cinnamon +7 other notes
|
5 |
| Bastardo
WestMan Shaving |
 Spicy |
West Indian Bay · Orange · Patchouli · Bay Rum · Cinnamon · Citrusy +11 other notes
|
2 |
| BAY GUM
Phoenix Artisan Accoutrements Limited |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Bay Rum · Citrus (unspecified) · Citrusy · Fresh · Fruity +4 other notes
|
5 |
| Bay Rum
Barrister and Mann |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Orange · Bay Rum · Benzoin · Cinnamon · Citrusy +5 other notes
|
4 |
| Bay Rum
Captain's Choice |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Bay Rum · Cinnamon · Citrus (unspecified) · Spices (unspecified) +4 other notes
|
2 |
| Bay Rum
Chiseled Face |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Ginger · Vanilla · Bay Rum · Bergamot · Black Pepper +8 other notes
|
4 |
| Bay Rum
Clubman Pinaud |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Bay Rum · Cinnamon · Clove · Floral · Floral (unspecified) +6 other notes
|
2 |
| Bay Rum
Col. Conk |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Rum +1 other note
|
4 |
| Bay Rum
Darwin Shaving |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Ambergris · Bay Laurel · Cade · Citron · Frankincense +6 other notes
|
1 |
| Bay Rum
Ethos Grooming Essentials |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Allspice / Pimento · Bay Rum · Cinnamon · Clove · Lime +8 other notes
|
2 |
| Bay Rum
Fine Accoutrements |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Bay Rum · Citrus (unspecified) · Resinous / Balsamic · Resins (unspecified) · Spices (unspecified) +5 other notes
|
2 |
| Bay Rum
Geo. F. Trumper |
Spicy |
West Indian Bay · Bergamot · Clove · Citrus (unspecified) · Fresh · Spicy +3 other notes
|
1 |
| Bay Rum
Hendrix Classics & Co. |
Spicy |
West Indian Bay · Orange · Bay Rum · Citrusy · Herbal / Aromatic · Soapy / Clean +2 other notes
|
3 |
| Bay Rum
Lather & Wood Shaving Co. |
Spicy |
West Indian Bay · Barbershop · Bay Rum · Cinnamon · Citrus (unspecified) · Clove +6 other notes
|
2 |
| Bay Rum
Le Père Lucien |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Bay Laurel · Bay Rum · Rose · Sandalwood · Warm +4 other notes
|
2 |
| Bay Rum
Stirling Soap Co. |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Bay Rum · Cinnamon · Clove · Nutmeg · Orange +5 other notes
|
6 |
| Bay Rum
Taylor of Old Bond Street |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Bay Rum · Hair Tonic · Rum · Spicy +3 other notes
|
1 |
| Bay Rum
Wet Shaving Products |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Allspice / Pimento · Bay Rum · Cinnamon · Lime · Rum +5 other notes
|
1 |
| Bay Rum No. 28
Barberry Coast Shave Co. |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Citrus (unspecified) · Orange · Cinnamon · Allspice / Pimento · Clove +11 other notes
|
4 |
| Bay Rum, Sage & Cedar
Bay Rum Ogallala |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Barbershop · Bay Rum · Cedar · Herbal / Aromatic · Sage +4 other notes
|
2 |
| Black Beard
Black Ship Grooming |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Bay Rum · Lime · Menthol · Spicy +3 other notes
|
1 |
| Blue Spice
Lustray |
Spicy |
West Indian Bay · Berries (unspecified) · Black Pepper · Caraway · Cinnamon · Frankincense +8 other notes
|
1 |
| Boomtown Bay Rum
Phoenix Artisan Accoutrements |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Coconut · Peach · Vanilla · Animalic · Bay Rum +18 other notes
|
6 |
| Bull and Bell Series: Bay Rum
Murphy and McNeil |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Bay Rum · Citrus (unspecified) · Fresh · Rum +3 other notes
|
1 |
| Captain Smythe's Oak Barrel Aged Bay Rum & Leather
Phoenix Artisan Accoutrements |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Bay Rum · Leather · Oak · Woody +3 other notes
|
1 |
| Coconut Bay
Phoenix Artisan Accoutrements |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Lime · Bay Rum · Citrusy · Coconut · Creamy +4 other notes
|
5 |
| Cuba
Czech & Speake |
Spicy |
West Indian Bay · Bergamot · Lime · Peppermint · Rum · Clove +10 other notes
|
3 |
| Imperial Rum
Phoenix and Beau |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Lime · Orange · Allspice / Pimento · Black Pepper · Cinnamon +10 other notes
|
3 |
| Island Estate
Sir Henry's |
Spicy |
West Indian Bay · Citrus (unspecified) · Vanilla · Bay Rum +3 other notes
|
2 |
| Laureato
Abbate y la Mantia |
 Aromatic / Herbal |
West Indian Bay · Almond · Camphor · Lemon · Bay Laurel · Hawthorn +7 other notes
|
2 |
| Magens Bay
Nomad Theory |
Spicy |
West Indian Bay · Black Pepper · Lime · Orange · Cinnamon · Clove +8 other notes
|
3 |
| Nature Isle
Barberry Coast Shave Co. |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Lime · Talc · Tonka Bean · Vanilla · Musk +10 other notes
|
4 |
| Pineapple Bay Rum
Phoenix Artisan Accoutrements |
Spicy |
West Indian Bay · Bay Rum · Pineapple +2 other notes
|
1 |
| Santa Monica Bay Rum
Chiseled Face |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Bay Rum · Clary Sage · Ho Wood · Opoponax · Orange +8 other notes
|
2 |
| Scapicchio
Captain Fawcett |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Bay Rum · Fig · Olive +3 other notes
|
2 |
| Sea Ice Lime
Seaforth! |
 Citrus |
West Indian Bay · Bergamot · Cedar · Coriander Seed · Fresh · Lime +7 other notes
|
3 |
| Sea Spice Lime
Seaforth! |
Citrus |
West Indian Bay · Bergamot · Cedar · Coriander Seed · Lime · Oakmoss +7 other notes
|
3 |
| Soltomic!
Phoenix Artisan Accoutrements |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Allspice / Pimento · Benzoin · Blood Orange · Cedar · Cinnamon +12 other notes
|
1 |
| Supreme Sandal Nuts
Phoenix Artisan Accoutrements |
 Woody |
West Indian Bay · Coconut · Lime · Sandalwood · Spices (unspecified) +4 other notes
|
1 |
| Tortola
Ethos Grooming Essentials |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Bay Rum · Coconut · Lime · Mandarin · Orange +7 other notes
|
2 |
| Trade Winds
Moon Soaps |
Spicy |
West Indian Bay · Bergamot · Cedar · Fresh · Lime · Tobacco +4 other notes
|
3 |
| Triumph
Stirling Soap Co. |
 Aquatic / Marine |
West Indian Bay · Citrus (unspecified) · Floral (unspecified) · Fresh · Sea Notes +3 other notes
|
5 |
| Virgin Island Bay Rum
Clubman Pinaud |
Bay Rum |
West Indian Bay · Bay Rum · Cinnamon · Clove · Rum · Spices (unspecified) +5 other notes
|
2 |
| Washington
Heritage Hill Shave Company |
Woody |
West Indian Bay · Fir · Orange · Jasmine · Patchouli · Woody +4 other notes
|
3 |
| West Indies
Tallow + Steel |
Citrus |
West Indian Bay · Amyris · Vetiver · Allspice / Pimento · Black Pepper · Coconut +6 other notes
|
2 |
